In recent months, China Duty Free Group (CDFG) has found itself in a whirlwind of mixed emotions as it navigates a complex landscape marked by both newfound opportunities and daunting challengesThe company, a dominant player in China's duty-free retail space, has made significant gains in certain areas, yet these have not been enough to stave off a steep decline in overall performance.

On the positive side, two major developments have caught the eye of industry insidersFirstly, CDFG continues to maintain its oligopolistic stronghold in its core businessAccording to the mid-year report for 2024, revenue from Hainan province accounted for an impressive 53.89% of the company's total earningsWhat’s more, CDFG's market share in Hainan's offshore duty-free sector has grown by 2 percentage points, showcasing its ability to reinforce its competitive edge despite a challenging economic backdropThis was no small feat, as the increased presence of competitors— with ten companies now holding duty-free licenses including heavyweights like Wangfujing and Zhuhai Duty Free— intended to intensify market competitionYet, CDFG not only survived but thrived, affirming the resilience of its brand power and the strategic value of its licenses.

Secondly, the growth rate in CDFG's airport duty-free revenue has been particularly strikingIn 2024, the revenue generated by the company's duty-free outlets in Beijing's airports soared by over 115% year-on-year, while those in Shanghai saw nearly a 32% increaseThis uptick in airport retail sales suggests a rebound in an area previously hit hard by external shocks, reflecting changing consumer travel patterns and renewed confidence among travelers.

However, this silver lining is overshadowed by a stark reality: the company is grappling with a significant drop in overall revenuesIn January 2025, CDFG forecasted a staggering projected revenue of ¥564.92 billion for 2024, which marks a 16.36% decline compared to the previous year, while net profits are expected to plummet by 36.5% to ¥42.63 billion

Advertisements

The projected downturn stands in stark contrast to the promising growth in airport sales, underscoring a worrying trend wherein CDFG’s performance appears to be deteriorating, particularly as the fourth quarter of 2024 is anticipated to continue this downward trajectoryBy the end of the first three quarters of 2024, the company had already reported revenues of ¥430.21 billion—a 15.38% decline from the previous year—with net profits of ¥39.19 billion decreasing by 24.72%.

Adding to the hardship, the adjustments made to the airport minimum rental fees—which were supposed to alleviate some financial pressure—have yet to translate into improved profitability for CDFGAs of 2023, the company incurred sales expenses totaling ¥94.21 billion, with rental costs alone accounting for ¥42.69 billion, which represents over 45% of expensesIt's noteworthy that the company's net profit reported for that period stood at just ¥67.14 billionTo mitigate financial strain, CDFG entered into supplemental agreements with both Beijing and Shanghai airports at the end of 2023 to significantly lower minimum rental costsNonetheless, this strategy has yet to produce felt results, with the net profit margin falling from 10.76% in 2023 to just 10.02% in the first three quarters of 2024, indicating a troubling trend that has persisted despite structural changes.

Perhaps even more alarming is the sharp decline in cash flowIn the first three quarters of 2024, the net cash flow generated from operational activities dwindled to a mere ¥51.04 billion, marking an extraordinary drop of ¥83.39 billion or 62.03% in year-on-year termsSimultaneously, the cash received from sales and service provision also decreased by nearly ¥88 billion compared to the prior year, suggesting a noticeable contraction in CDFG's sales collection capabilitiesThis financial squeeze has resulted in significant inventory buildup, as the company's inventory reached ¥186.87 billion during the same period

Advertisements

While this amount reflects a year-on-year decrease of ¥41.73 billion, it remains substantially higher than the pre-pandemic inventory level of ¥80.6 billion recorded in 2019.

Considering the competitive advantages that CDFG possesses, one must ponder why the company is facing such adverse outcomesThe primary culprit appears to be a general softening in duty-free consumer spendingWhile market share in Hainan's offshore duty-free sector has increased, it does not correlate with improved financial performance because the overall market has contractedAccording to industry statistics, the total duty-free shopping volume in Hainan dropped to ¥30.94 billion in 2024, a significant decline of 29.3% from the previous yearFurthermore, in 2024, the number of duty-free shoppers in Hainan fell to 5.683 million, down 15.9%, while the total number of purchases decreased by an alarming 35.5%. This data points to a troubling trend where shopping expenditures and quantities have plummeted even more severely than the number of consumers, hinting at a troubling contraction in buying power.

In addition to waning demand, consumption has become progressively fragmented due to external factorsInternational travel has seen a resurgence, diverting potential shoppers away from HainanPreviously, in the wake of global challenges, many tourists opted for domestic travel and took advantage of enhanced duty-free shopping limits set in 2020. However, as international tourism continues to thrive, CDFG is experiencing a significant impact on its consumer base, akin to a thunderbolt striking from a clear skyAdditionally, the rise of cross-border e-commerce has compounded the problem, offering cheaper alternatives to duty-free products, which diminishes CDFG's pricing advantageAs Chinese consumers become increasingly budget-conscious, a shift to online shopping could further divert sales away from traditional retail spaces.

Reflecting on CDFG's perceived slip from grace, it becomes apparent that despite the company’s retained advantage in license acquisition and its leading status, external factors such as declining duty-free spending and consumer fragmentation have significantly impacted overall performance and profitability

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements